|
|
|
|
FRP
Rebar
The Need
|
Reinforced
Concrete is a very common building material for the
construction of facilities and structures. As complement to
concrete's very limited tensile strength, steel rebar has been
an effective and cost-efficient reinforcement.
However, insufficient concrete cover, poor design or
workmanship, and presence of large amounts of aggressive
agents including environmental factors all can lead to
cracking of the concrete and corrosion of the steel rebar. For
instance, in the USA, almost 40% of bridges are structurally
deficient or functionally obsolete, and the percentage is
increasing, according to the Federal Highway Administration (Griffiths
2000)
For many years, there have been many studies on this corrosion
issue, and the interest in FRP (Fiber Reinforced Polymer) has
arisen recently as prospective substitute for steel. Careful
consideration on potential of FRP rebar to fill the cost and
performance needs may suggest appropriate solutions.
|

Notre-Dame Hospital used for
magnetic neutrality in MRI room
(Pultrall, ADS Composites Group, 1995)

Caissons and port facilities
(Pultrall, ADS Composites Group) |
The Technology
|
Recently,
composite materials made of fibers embedded in a polymeric
resin, also known as fiber-reinforced polymers, have become an
alternative to steel reinforcement for concrete structures.
Aramid fiber reinforced polymer (AFRP), carbon fiber
reinforced polymer (CFRP), and glass fiber reinforced polymer
(GFRP) rods are the commercially available products for the
construction industry. They have been proposed for use in lieu
of steel reinforcement or steel prestressing tendons in
nonprestressed or prestressed concrete structures (ACI 440R
2006). The problems of steel corrosion are avoided with the
use of FRPs because FRP materials are nonmetallic and
noncorrosive. In addition, FRP materials exhibit several
properties including high tensile strength, that make them
suitable for the use as structural reinforcement. Furthermore,
codes and design guide provisions have been recently prepared
for the use of FRP bars in concrete structures for bridges and
buildings (ACI 440H 2000; CSA 2000; ISIS-Canada 2000). |

Hall's Harbor - World's first
fully composite reinforcement Warf
(Pultrall, ADS Composites Group; Hughes Brothers, Inc.)

Dry Dock #4 Peal Harbor, Hawaii
(Hughes Brothers, Inc)
Click on the picture for larger one
|
|
The bond characteristics are responsible to transfer the load
from concrete to reinforcement and to develop the required
stress in the reinforcement for an equilibrium, particularly
when concrete is cracked. Service limits in FRP reinforced
concrete elements such as deflection, crack width and crack
spacing are directly influenced by the bond properties of the
reinforcement in concrete.
Fiber reinforced polymer bars are anisotropic materials.
Factors such as type and volume of fiber and resin, fiber
orientation and quality control during the manufacturing play
a major role in the mechanical characteristics.
In the case of Carbon FRP rebar (CFRP Isorod bar from Pultrall,
ADS Composites Group), when comparing a steel bar of 11.3
mm diameter with CFRP rebar with similar diameter of about 9.5
mm, the results shows that the tensile stress-strain curves of
the CFRP bar are linear up to failure (All FRP bars are linear
elastic to failure). The ultimate tensile
strength is at least 1500 MPa, 3 times that of steel rebar.
The modulus of elasticity of the CFRP bar is 128 GPa, about
65% that of steel. The CFRP bar exhibited almost the same bond
strength to concrete as 11.3 mm diameter steel bar. (Benmokrane
et al. 2001)
As for Glass FRP bar (ASLAN 100 GFRP bar from Hughes Brothers,
Inc.), tensile strength of 9 mm GFRP bar is 760 MPa, and the
Modulus of Elasticity is 40.8 GPa, much lower than that of
steel. Fiberglass
rebar may be a suitable alternative to steel reinforcing in:
-
Architectural
Concrete: cast stone, architectural cladding, balusters,
column facades, window lentils, architectural precast
elements, hand railing, and statuary and fountains, etc.
-
Concrete
exposed to de-icing salts in: bridge decks, railroad grade
crossings, median barriers, parking garage elements, and
salt storage facilities, etc.
-
Concrete
exposed to marine salts in: seawalls, water breaks,
buildings & structures near waterfront, aquaculture
operations, and floating marine docks, etc.
-
Concrete
used near electromagnetic equipment such as: MRI rooms in
hospitals, airport radio & compass calibration pads,
and concrete near high voltage cables, transformers,
substations, etc.
|
The Benefits
|
-
Impervious
to chloride ion and chemical attack
-
Tensile
strength greater than steel
-
1/4th
weight of steel reinforcement
-
Transparent
to magnetic fields and radio frequencies
-
Electrically
and thermally non-conductive
Based on
features above, FRP bars appear to be promising alternative to
steel reinforcement in concrete structures such as marine
structures, parking structures, bridge decks, highway under
extreme environments, and structures highly susceptible to
corrosion and magnetic fields. |
Status
|
The earliest commercial uses of FRP composite rebar are
approximately twenty-five years old. These original
applications were for non-magnetic or radio-frequency transparent
reinforcements for magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)
medical equipment and specialized defense applications.
|

Concreting - Floodway Bridge, Winnipeg, Canada (Huges Brothers)
|
|
FRP
composite rebars have emerged as the industry standard for
this application, eclipsing stainless steel in recent years. As recently as the
1990s, the deteriorating state of the U.S. infrastructure,
particularly vehicular highway bridges, caused alternative
reinforcements to be considered. Parallel interest in Europe
and Japan has helped to make FRP composite rebar an
international research topic. According to ACI 440H, the
Japanese lead in this field, with more than 100 demonstration
projects reported in the literature.
One of most important developments is the publication of
ACI440.3R-04
published to support the ACI 440 design guides, with the
understanding that in due time these test methods would
transition to the more formal ASTM body.
The document is available from ACI and provides the practicing
engineering with the necessary information to implement these
new FRP bars.
This transitioning is now occurring and documents such as ASTM
D7205 now describe test methods for determining tensile,
modulus and strain properties of FRP bars. Several other test
methods are also in the process of being printed in the ASTM
consensus reviewed format.
In addition, FRP Rebar Manufacturers Council (Chairman: Doug
Gremel) was formed by the manufacturers listed on the 'Points
of Contact' with the objective of fostering quality
assurance and other industry standards amongst manufacturers.
|
|
- The Canadian Highway bridge design code, CSA - S6-06 now
includes provisions which allow for the use of GFRP rebar.
Consequently, a number of bridges in Canada are being built in
on a more routine basis. The largest of these projects to
date is the "Floodway Bridge" near Winnipeg. This is a
significant bridge structure by any measure but more so due to
fact that it was built using the "steel free deck" concept
using all GFFRP bars in the concrete above the girders. |

Deck Rodbusting - Floodway Bridge, Winnipeg, Canada (Huges Brothers) |
Barriers
|
The
cost of FRP rebar in $/ft is typically higher than conventional
steel rebar. Carbon FRP is usually more expensive then GFRP.
Click here
to find a detailed cost catalog for FRP rebar.
It should be noted that
it is not possible to make a direct substitution from steel bars
to FRP without applying the design principles of the appropriate
guide. In general, the cost impact to use GFRP bars in a bridge
deck is only raising the cost of the deck by something on the
order of 2 to 5% these days. So, to utilize GFRP bars and
potentially gain many extra years of service life may not an
expensive alternative.
- The
cost is $3 to $4/lb (including approx. $1/lb of raw
material cost) in case of Glass FRP bar, and Carbon FRP is
usually more expensive. (cf. Epoxy coated rebar costs
$0.32/lb)
-
Due to the
lack of well-established standards, a wide variety of FRP bars
is today commercialized, going from the simple smooth bars to
bars treated to improve bond characteristics. Therefore, a
better understanding of mechanical properties and bond
behavior is needed for a rational approach to the design of
FRP reinforced structures.
- Field
bends are not allowed, and not-weldable, so consideration
on differences in construction operations of regular steel
rebar should be applied from the design phase.
- Lack
of familiarity by practicing engineers can cause lower
productivity than prospected.
|
Points of Contact
-
Gremel,
Doug. Director, Non-Metallic Reinforcing, Hughes Brothers, Inc.
210 N. 13th Street, Seward, NE 68464 Phone: (402) 646-6211 Fax:
(402) 643-2149 Email: doug@hughesbros.com
Website: http://www.hughesbros.com
-
Dow Chemical -
Fulcrum Company. Building 3 #4, 312 Washington Street, Wellesley
Hills, MA 02481 Phone: (781) 431-6439 Fax: (800) 409-4144 Email:
drvanderpool@dow.com
Website: http://www.dow.com
-
Pultrall, ADS
Composites Group. 1191, Rue Huppe, Thetford Mines, Quebec G6G
7Y6, Canada Phone: (418) 335-3202 Fax: (418) 335-5117 Email: eric.martin@adsinc.ca
-
Marshall
Industries Composites, Inc. 2250 Central Point Parkway, Lima, OH
45804 Phone: (419) 221-1444 Fax: (419) 222-5442 Email: info@c-bar.com
Website: http://www.c-bar.com
-
FRP Rebar Manufacturers Council.
600 Mamaroneck Ave. 4th Floor, Harrison, NY 10528-1632 Phone:
(914) 381-3572 Fax: (914) 381-1253
References
-
Marshall
Industries Composites, Inc. Website: http://www.c-bar.com
-
Hughes Brothers,
Inc. Website: http://www.hughesbros.com
-
Griffiths, J. R.
"Plastic Highway Bridges", Cambridge Scientific
Abstracts, 2000
-
Benmokrane et al.
"Mechanical and Bond Properties of New Generation of ISOROD
CFRP Reinforcing Bars for Concrete Structures", technical
progress report, 2001, ISIS Canada
- Market Development Alliance of the
FRP Composite Industry (MDA) Website: http://www.MDAcomposites.org
- Gremel, D. "FRP Rebar - A
State of the Industry Report Manufacturing, Construction,
Economics and Marketing", Proceedings of the Workshop
Composites in Construction: A Reality, 20-21 Jul., 2001,
Anacapri, Italy.
Disclaimer Statement
|
Neither the Construction
Industry Institute nor Purdue University in any way endorses this
technology or represents
that the information presented can be relied upon without further investigation. |
JK20
|
|